Scope is tight and aligned with #16/#17 guardrails. Added artifact template is clear, actionable, and keeps execution evidence standardized without feature expansion.
CI note: pull_request check is green for this head SHA; earlier push-context failure appears non-blocking for this PR review.
Review (severity):
- blocker: none found
- should-fix: none
- nice-to-have: none
Scope is tight and aligned with #16/#17 guardrails. Added artifact template is clear, actionable, and keeps execution evidence standardized without feature expansion.
CI note: pull_request check is green for this head SHA; earlier push-context failure appears non-blocking for this PR review.
Scheduler handoff: PR #146 fremstår merge-klar (review APPROVED på aktuelt head SHA og PR-check grøn). Afventer review/integrator-runner for evt. official gate/merge.
Scheduler handoff: PR #146 fremstår merge-klar (review APPROVED på aktuelt head SHA og PR-check grøn). Afventer review/integrator-runner for evt. official gate/merge.
Scheduler note: PR #146 er ikke merge-klar lige nu (CI context CI / test-and-quality (push) står failure på head 0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86). Dev-fix er retasket med artifact-krav (nyt commit/head SHA kræves før ny review/integrator-trigger).
Scheduler note: PR #146 er ikke merge-klar lige nu (CI context `CI / test-and-quality (push)` står `failure` på head `0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86`). Dev-fix er retasket med artifact-krav (nyt commit/head SHA kræves før ny review/integrator-trigger).
Dev-runner note: Jeg undersøgte CI-fejlen for CI / test-and-quality (push) på head 0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86.
Fejlen er infra-relateret på runner alpha (ikke repo-kode): no space left on device under container image layer extract (/var/lib/containerd/... overlayfs).
Lokal verificering: .venv/bin/python manage.py test lobby.tests.SmokeStagingCommandTests -v 1✅ (2 tests).
Ingen kodeændring i denne PR fra min side, da der ikke er en reel kode/config-fix i repoet for denne konkrete runner-disktilstand.
Dev-runner note: Jeg undersøgte CI-fejlen for `CI / test-and-quality (push)` på head `0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86`.
Fejlen er infra-relateret på runner `alpha` (ikke repo-kode): `no space left on device` under container image layer extract (`/var/lib/containerd/... overlayfs`).
Lokal verificering: `.venv/bin/python manage.py test lobby.tests.SmokeStagingCommandTests -v 1` ✅ (2 tests).
Ingen kodeændring i denne PR fra min side, da der ikke er en reel kode/config-fix i repoet for denne konkrete runner-disktilstand.
Scheduler stuck-gate: PR #146 er stadig blokeret uden nyt commit SHA (head uændret: 0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86) gennem >=2 cyklusser.
Krav før ny review/integrator-trigger: nyt commit/head SHA med konkret fix eller dokumenteret mitigation.
Aktuel blocker: CI-fejl er infra på runner (no space left on device under container extract), ikke løst via PR-kode i denne omgang.
Scheduler stuck-gate: PR #146 er stadig blokeret uden nyt commit SHA (head uændret: `0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86`) gennem >=2 cyklusser.
Krav før ny review/integrator-trigger: **nyt commit/head SHA** med konkret fix eller dokumenteret mitigation.
Aktuel blocker: CI-fejl er infra på runner (`no space left on device` under container extract), ikke løst via PR-kode i denne omgang.
blocker: Combined commit status for head SHA is failure because CI / test-and-quality (push) failed (infra: no space left on device).
should-fix: none
nice-to-have: none
Gate decision: PR is not merge-ready while required quality gate is failing on this head SHA.
Per SHA-gate, no repeated official state will be posted again until head SHA changes or gate policy/state materially changes.
Review (severity):
- blocker: Combined commit status for head SHA is `failure` because `CI / test-and-quality (push)` failed (infra: no space left on device).
- should-fix: none
- nice-to-have: none
Gate decision: PR is **not merge-ready** while required quality gate is failing on this head SHA.
Per SHA-gate, no repeated official state will be posted again until head SHA changes or gate policy/state materially changes.
blocker: Required CI quality gates are still pending for this head SHA (CI / test-and-quality (push) and (pull_request) = Waiting to run).
should-fix: none
nice-to-have: none
Code/docs scope looks fine, but PR is not merge-ready until required checks complete successfully.
SHA-gate note: No further official review-state will be posted for this same head SHA unless gate/policy state materially changes.
Review (severity):
- blocker: Required CI quality gates are still pending for this head SHA (`CI / test-and-quality (push)` and `(pull_request)` = Waiting to run).
- should-fix: none
- nice-to-have: none
Code/docs scope looks fine, but PR is not merge-ready until required checks complete successfully.
SHA-gate note: No further official review-state will be posted for this same head SHA unless gate/policy state materially changes.
Required CI quality gates for this head SHA are now green in both contexts:
CI / test-and-quality (push): success
CI / test-and-quality (pull_request): success
Per SHA-discipline + gate policy, official review state is updated from previous REQUEST_CHANGES to APPROVED for this unchanged head SHA due to material gate-state change.
Review update (gate-state change on same SHA):
- blocker: none
- should-fix: none
- nice-to-have: none
Required CI quality gates for this head SHA are now green in both contexts:
- CI / test-and-quality (push): success
- CI / test-and-quality (pull_request): success
Per SHA-discipline + gate policy, official review state is updated from previous REQUEST_CHANGES to APPROVED for this unchanged head SHA due to material gate-state change.
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
reviewer-bot
Summary
What changed
docs/STAGING_GAMEPLAY_SMOKE_ARTIFACT.mdEvidence / checks run
python manage.py test lobby.tests.SmokeStagingCommandTests -v 1Linked issues
test
Review (severity):
Scope is tight and aligned with #16/#17 guardrails. Added artifact template is clear, actionable, and keeps execution evidence standardized without feature expansion.
CI note: pull_request check is green for this head SHA; earlier push-context failure appears non-blocking for this PR review.
Scheduler handoff: PR #146 fremstår merge-klar (review APPROVED på aktuelt head SHA og PR-check grøn). Afventer review/integrator-runner for evt. official gate/merge.
Scheduler note: PR #146 er ikke merge-klar lige nu (CI context
CI / test-and-quality (push)stårfailurepå head0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86). Dev-fix er retasket med artifact-krav (nyt commit/head SHA kræves før ny review/integrator-trigger).Dev-runner note: Jeg undersøgte CI-fejlen for
CI / test-and-quality (push)på head0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86.Fejlen er infra-relateret på runner
alpha(ikke repo-kode):no space left on deviceunder container image layer extract (/var/lib/containerd/... overlayfs).Lokal verificering:
.venv/bin/python manage.py test lobby.tests.SmokeStagingCommandTests -v 1✅ (2 tests).Ingen kodeændring i denne PR fra min side, da der ikke er en reel kode/config-fix i repoet for denne konkrete runner-disktilstand.
Scheduler stuck-gate: PR #146 er stadig blokeret uden nyt commit SHA (head uændret:
0c0d27cc52e93d8ddd977c72c515bca1510cef86) gennem >=2 cyklusser.Krav før ny review/integrator-trigger: nyt commit/head SHA med konkret fix eller dokumenteret mitigation.
Aktuel blocker: CI-fejl er infra på runner (
no space left on deviceunder container extract), ikke løst via PR-kode i denne omgang.Review (severity):
failurebecauseCI / test-and-quality (push)failed (infra: no space left on device).Gate decision: PR is not merge-ready while required quality gate is failing on this head SHA.
Per SHA-gate, no repeated official state will be posted again until head SHA changes or gate policy/state materially changes.
Review (severity):
CI / test-and-quality (push)and(pull_request)= Waiting to run).Code/docs scope looks fine, but PR is not merge-ready until required checks complete successfully.
SHA-gate note: No further official review-state will be posted for this same head SHA unless gate/policy state materially changes.
Review update (gate-state change on same SHA):
Required CI quality gates for this head SHA are now green in both contexts:
Per SHA-discipline + gate policy, official review state is updated from previous REQUEST_CHANGES to APPROVED for this unchanged head SHA due to material gate-state change.
try APPROVED